I felt my foot snap as my body crashed on the sidewalk. I knew something bad had happened. I breathed to relax and, in a strange way, a calm energy came over me. It was a calm that had rarely visited me since we moved to Florence six months prior. I got up and started limping towards my house along the Arno. The buildings and lights twinkled on the other side of the river. Florence was also serene, and it felt like we were making peace for a short time.

Why did I hate Florence? First of all, it didn’t make me happy. I was waiting to be served a chunk of contentment the size of the Duomo, all while I was sitting down and doing nothing. Second, Florence can be ruthless. Somewhere between the flocks of tourists and the Florentines who always keep you at arm’s length, amid the bureaucracy, incompetence, delayed buses and retrofitted schools, the city tests your resilience and sanity in thousands of small ways. If we’re talking about over-tourism, for example, Florence’s own beauty can make her borderline ugly at times. Third, Florence was holding up a mirror, where I could see all the unhappiness, victimhood and entitlement that had always been there within me. I didn’t like it one bit.
We had planned to make a move for a while. I wanted New York, my wife pushed for Florence, and so we decided to go for her dream first, but then life happened and it became a brutal shift, just a month and a half after my father passed away. Like many couples with a small kid, things were tense between us and moving to Florence also meant being forced to overcome the financial fears that had plagued me my entire life. I was burned out and working hard to find a piece of dolce far niente.
When the first winter came, I found solace in empty movie theaters, connecting in silence with other souls, watching Italian films and not understanding a word. Another decision I had made was not to learn the language, partly because I was overwhelmed and partly out of spite. At my lowest, I found myself strolling around piazza Santa Croce, stopping in front of Dante’s statue and asking him for life advice. What should I do? “Move forward,” he responded. What about my writing? “Just write.” It was enough fuel to go another day.

Two years later, I still held on to Florence, even when my wife was starting to give in. It became personal; I refused to lose this man-versus-city battle. At the same time, I could finally see through my excuses and it wasn’t a pretty sight. Florence wasn’t as bad as I was petrified. I was scared of the unknown and harbouring a liquifying anxiety about moving abroad over 40. Little by little, I admitted my fears and challenged them. It was painful, but I was maturing. Breaking my foot helped expedite the process.
Big change came in the form of joining The Social Hub, connecting with fellow writers at the Florence Literary Society, going for Saturday community runs in Mensola park and to church on Sundays. The city continued to test and humble me. I found my way, lost it, found it and lost it again until I stripped away the non-essentials and focused on what mattered to me: my family, the book I’m writing, connecting with people and helping them through coaching.
Indeed, people were the one constant, always there when I wasn’t scared of them, judging, labeling or finding excuses not to bond. Florence can be giving and nurturing, showing generosity through soulful events and diverse stories. Yet I experienced a city that requires constant effort to live a good life.
I even ran my first marathon here and the 100-kilometre Il Passatore ultramarathon until I found the courage to do the really hard things: apply for residency, learn Italian and stop complaining to my wife about Florence. How else could we find out if this place is truly for us if we don’t give it everything we have? And how could I show my daughter all this city has to offer?
I suffered more than I can say in this city, experienced wins and losses, reveled in the beauty, hurt in the loneliness and rejoiced in connection. In a way, I came here as a boy and became a man. Thank you, Florence.